Seeing the Light LEDs Promise Savings, Longer Life

Seeing the Light

 Lighting in the U.S. alone accounts for approximately 22 percent of all  electricity used, according to the U.S. Department of Energy. It is no wonder  that in the current economic and environmentally-sensitive climate a lot of  effort is going towards finding, improving and engineering new and improved  light sources.  

 Among those innovations are light-emitting diodes, better known as LEDs. Despite  the fact that LEDs have been around for decades, with recent improvements they  have become the most promising “low hanging fruit” around for energy conservation in lighting.  

 Using far less energy than even Compact Fluorescent Lights (CFLs)—today’s gold standard for thriftiness—they also promise life spans many times longer than conventional lighting. For  this reason, LEDs are turning up in High-Def TVs, in your local hardware aisle  and in early-adopter condominiums.  

 Savings Outdoors

 Condos looking to invest in LED technology are hoping to see positive results  along the lines of the Palace Pier in Toronto, Canada. This 46-floor condo  complex underwent a $2.4 million lighting renovation in 2008. The traditional  halogen lights in all the interior corridors were replaced with new LED lights.  Usage shifted dramatically from 35 watts of electricity under the old lighting  to only 4 watts after the conversion. It’s predicted that the Palace Pier will use 87 percent less energy and the switch  from halogen to LED will eventually save approximately $40,000 per year with an  estimated 110-ton reduction in greenhouse gas emissions.  

 Along with condominiums, numerous cities around the world are switching to LEDs,  including Boston, which recently upgraded sections of the Boston Common with  LED-powered lampposts on walking paths and sidewalks. The LEDs are proposed to  use less than half of the energy of the previous lights and last three to four  times longer. Boston has also been replacing traffic signals and pedestrian  crossing lights with LEDs at a projected cost savings of nearly $400,000  annually.  

 A shopping plaza in Manchester, New Hampshire also saved considerable money by  making the switch, replacing 22 high-pressure sodium lights and six  metal-halide lights with 25 LEDs. Occupancy sensors were also installed,  allowing light output to change when cars were present. This not only resulted  in a 58 percent energy savings but the return on investment is expected to take  only three years.  

 Today, metal halide and sodium- or mercury-vapor lamps are typically used to  light condo parking lots and garages, but some communities are making the  switch to LEDs for the same reasons as the city of Boston and the shopping  center in Manchester.  

 In fact, that's one of the fastest-growing markets for LED lighting, says Gary  Rosenfield, general manager of JuiceWorks LLC, a joint venture company with Sea  Gull Lighting/parent company Generation Brands, based in Cary, North Carolina. “This is due to not only the quality of light, but the savings on energy and  maintenance that LED lighting offers. Of course, all lighting needs to meet the  requirements of the National Electrical Code, and certifying agencies for  safety and fire prevention.” Condos should also make sure that installed outdoor LEDs are able to keep dust  and water vapors out of the fixtures.  

 Condo Interior Uses

 LEDs also work well indoors, as long as they're used in the right location. As  the Palace Pier found, to get the most from their investment, condos should  concentrate on installing the lighting in areas that get the most use and  require consistent long-duration illumination. Lobbies and hallways are  potentially well-suited for LEDs, whereas little-used mechanical rooms and  closets are less optimal and will have a far greater payback time. Low-traffic,  infrequently used areas lend themselves better to use of fluorescents.  

 As for concerns about the quality of the light thrown by next-generation bulbs  and diodes, “There are two ways to go really,” says Max Hoover of GoodMart in New York City. “One, you have a screw-in compact fluorescent light bulb or screw-in incandescent  light bulb. My co-op, for example, has all incandescents. And nobody wants to  seem to change the ambiance, but that's not really a valid argument anymore.  You can just screw-in the LED light bulbs and they work great. They're dimmable  and have perfect ambiance—nice, warm white light, or you can put in the fixtures that were purpose-built  for the LEDs, which gives you significantly better performance. So if you're  doing a lobby remodel, that's the time to be looking at getting the right LED  fixtures from the get-go.”  

 “CFLs are better at creating soft patterns of light, where light is emitted in  all directions, such as a wall sconce or a decorative glowing pendant," says  Naomi Miller, senior lighting engineer at the Pacific Northwest National  Laboratory (a Department of Energy lab) in Portland, Oregon.  

 FAQs & Caveats

 Because LEDs are new and evolving rapidly, there are overstated claims about  their performance, cost savings and life span. Misinformation occurs partly  because many situationally-dependent variables come into play when assessing  cost, efficiency and life span of LEDs. The technology is also changing so fast  that most individuals find it hard to keep up with the ever-shifting product  specs. Sorting through the hype to get to the truth about LEDs can be  challenging for any condo. Here then, are some of the most common questions,  along with a little explanation.  

 Cost

 Most local utility providers and state energy offices now provide incentive  programs to condos making the switch to energy-efficient LEDs. Incentive  programs aside, condos can save money; however, calculating just how much in  savings will depend on many factors. These include:  

 • The type of LED lighting product selected.  

 • The expense of maintenance and upkeep (depends on the product selected).  

 • The cost of energy in the area the condo is located.  

 • The number of hours the LED lighting operates.  

 “The technology is ready now and costs are coming down,” says Rosenfield, “However, it is well known that there are still many manufacturers that are not  providing good quality LED products. We would advise selecting an LED product that is Energy Star approved as those  are meeting the highest standards for performance, reliability, and efficacy. Most utility companies offer incentives to switch to energy-efficient lighting,  which are readily available to both commercial and residential customers.”  

 "LEDs are pretty moderately priced around, around the same prices as CFLs," says  Joan Rice of Advantage Lighting & Electrical Supply in South Orange, New Jersey.  

 According to William Johnson, marketing manager of Cooper Lighting, a national  company based in Georgia, both LEDs and CFLs offer significant energy savings  and long life compared to incandescent light sources. “Dimming is also now available on CFL fixtures as well as for LED products.  Because CFL technology has been in practice for many years the cost for  residential CFL applications is lower than the newer LED technology. Yet LED  can offer even longer life than CFLs,” Johnson explains.  

 What About Rebates?

 Some energy companies do offer rebates to buildings changing over from  incandescent bulbs, particularly for large co-op or condo buildings. And if you  do change over, there is a rebate. You have to just check with your local  service provider.  

 "The rebate programs are just now starting to include LEDs in the list of  prescribed measures," says Hoover, "So that's sort of happening as we speak,  and depending on whether you're in New Jersey or New York, the rebate programs  differ. So it's really on a case-by-case basis. We would look at that and  maximize the rebate. As far as specials go, there are constantly new products  being introduced."  

 It's not a bad idea to consult with a lighting specialist, lighting engineer or  a lighting architect when exploring LED cost. Experts will be able to do a cost  analysis to determine the condo’s return on investment. “The technology is new enough that a specialist who is up to speed on LEDs is  worth the money,” says Miller.  

 Life Span

 “Typically, we see LEDs stated average rate of life up to 50,000 hours, whereas  the maximum life we've seen with CFLs is 15,000 hours,” says Hoover. “So that's advantage number one. Advantage number two is that LEDs can be up to  30 percent more efficient than CFLs. In other words, you start with how much  light you need, and then figure out what wattage lamp you need to get that  amount of light, you could end up with a lower wattage LED light bulb or light  fixture than you would with a CFL. Then advantage number three is environmental  superiority. Given the fact that the LED lasts longer, you're obviously buying  fewer things, you're transporting fewer things and using less fuel to do so.  You're putting fewer things in landfills. And CFLs contain mercury, which LEDs  do not. All the parts in [LEDs] meet strict environmental guidelines which CFLs  can't [because] they always contain small amounts of mercury.”  

 The multiple components that make up LEDs need to be factored into the life span  equation as well. What it boils down to is more parts, the more potential for  breakage—and not all components are created equal, performance-wise. “The LED chip itself may last 25,000 to 50,000 hours or longer. However, the driver/power supply may not last that long. It depends on the  product design and the heat it disperses and the heat of the environment in  which it is operating,” says Miller.  

 Johnson also notes the longer life span. “Compare a CFL of 12,000 hour average life and a LED that can offer over 50,000  hours life. A properly designed LED luminaire should last beyond 50,000 hours;  with 70 percent of the lumens still operating at that point,” he says. According to Johnson, LED light output diminishes very slowly over  time.  

 Typically, a three- to five-year warranty is given on LEDs. But industry  professionals warn that if condos will be using the LEDs less than 24/7, then a  three- to five-year warranty might not be long enough. Condos might need to  negotiate a longer warranty on their LED products. Likewise, it is important  that condos make sure they get a warranty on the life, light output, and color  consistency of the LED.  

 Light Quality

 According to Miller, “You get what you pay for” could not be a better saying when it comes to LED light quality. “Yes, there is a cost differential between nice light and ugly light with LEDs.  At this time the more expensive the LEDs, the better quality light."  

 LEDs should not be thought of as your average light bulb. In fact, they are  typically not a bulb at all. LEDs are lighting systems that have many different  components that work together with differing parts and elements to create  light. The most common format for LEDs are clustered in a shape that doesn't  look so very different from an ordinary light bulb, but the technology is very  flexible—diodes of nearly any color can be arranged into any type of array, limited only  by the designer's and client's imagination and budget.  

 Condos should “test” the LEDs out before fully installing them. Questions to ask are: is the color  and lighting being given off flattering to skin tones? Are the architectural  finishes in a space being enhanced or diminished by the introduction of the  LEDs? Is any amount of flicker being created? And how much glare is produced?  

 Here to Stay

 Manufacturers today are bringing to market LEDs that are packaged and configured  more like traditional bulbs. Heavy hitters such as GE and Panasonic are jumping  on the LED bandwagon with LED bulbs that have adaptive-fit capabilities for  screw-in fixtures. Still considered on the cusp of new technologies, these  bulbs presently have a fairly high price point and the entrance of these  powerhouses into the LED lighting market comes with some healthy skepticism.  

 However, Miller has a different spin: “It means LEDs are a technology that is here to stay," she says. "The major  players are producing some good products and backing them up with their  reputation and a warranty, but we should add that some of the new players in  the market are producing impressive products as well.”  

 As more residential buildings join the movement toward greener, more efficient  daily operations, LEDs and other emerging technologies offer options for  illuminating indoor and outdoor spaces while easing communities’ bottom lines and carbon footprints. Before your building super or handyman  replaces another burned-out incandescent bulb, it might be a bright idea to  look into these earth-friendly alternatives.   

 Hillary Pember is a freelance writer and a frequent contributor to New England  Condominium magazine, a Yale Robbins’ publication. Additional reporting by David Chiu.

Related Articles

Set of hands with posters, a megaphone, signs, banners and placards. Vector illustration in doodle style.

Political Signs, Bylaws, & Free Speech

Boards vs. the First Amendment

The concept of carbon neutral and net zero. natural environment A climate-neutral long-term strategy greenhouse gas emissions targets with green net center icon on hand cap and green background

Climate Change vs. Multifamily Systems

Hotter Summers, Wetter Winters Demand Adaptation

A hand holding money adjusting a thermostat on a wall.

Energy Recovery Ventilators

New Tech to Battle the Climate Crisis