Q&A: Collecting from a Bankrupt Owner

Q&A: Collecting from a Bankrupt Owner
Q “I own a condo in Southern New Jersey. An owner in our association is in arrears  of $1,300 on their monthly maintenance and has now filed for bankruptcy. Can we  still put a lien on the owner’s unit? If not, what can we do to recoup what’s owed our association? There are only 14 units and we do not have a property  management company. We generally take care of things ourselves to save money.  Do we have to hire a lawyer to represent our interests in this situation?”  

 —Concerned About Arrears  

A “You have indicated that you own a condominium in Southern New Jersey and that an  owner in the association is in arrears $1,300 on their monthly fees. That owner  has now filed for bankruptcy. You asked what the association can do to collect  on the money’s that are owed.  

 “First and foremost, the association is most likely precluded from filing a lien  representing the delinquent account,” says attorney Stuart J. Lieberman of the Princeton-based law firm of Lieberman & Blecher, P.C. “In most cases, associations have a right under the Condominium Act to file a  lien in cases where property owners are delinquent on their monthly  assessments. However, in the case of bankruptcy there is an automatic stay pursuant to  Section 362 of the Bankruptcy Code, which appears to preclude the association  from filing a lien.  

 “Specifically, once a bankruptcy petition is filed, most legal actions taken  against the bankrupt petitioner are put on hold. This is referred to by lawyers  as an ‘automatic stay.’ The effect of the automatic stay is that the bankrupt estate remains status quo,  so that the bankruptcy court can work things out and either allow for  reorganization or liquidation of the bankrupt estate.  

 “Among other things, the automatic stay precludes any act to create, perfect or  enforce a lien against the property of the estate or the property of the debtor  to the extent the lien secures a pre-petition claim. It therefore seems that the prudent and legally appropriate response is to not  file a lien against a unit owner who has filed for bankruptcy.  

 “This does not mean that the association has no remedies available to it once  bankruptcy has been filed. The association will be a creditor in the bankruptcy  case and will file a claim in the bankruptcy proceeding.  

 “Bankruptcy law establishes a hierarchy of claims, and certain claims go to the  head of the line and are paid first. The association’s lawyer will do what he or she can to try and make sure that as much of the  association’s claim for the arrearages is paid for out of the estate.  

 “Bankruptcy judges also have the ability to consider contested hearings involving  the bankrupt petitioner. This means that if the association needs to litigate  any part of its claim with the unit owner, the bankruptcy court has the ability  to hold a mini-hearing and resolve the dispute.  

 “Thus, the good news is that bankruptcy court provides a mechanism for  theoretically resolving arrearages involving a bankrupt unit owner. Experience  tells us, however, that in many instances these types of claims are not paid in  full out of the bankrupt estate. Sometimes, they are resolved through payment  of pennies on the dollar. Sometimes, the association receives nothing at all.  

 “The bottom line is that associations must be proactive and insure that unit  owners remain current on their monthly obligations. Especially in times such as  these, where the number of bankruptcy filings has escalated, staying on top of  arrearages before someone files for bankruptcy represents the most efficient  policy and the best advice that I can give you.”  

 

Related Articles

CAI Releases Statement on Foreclosure Moratorium

CAI Releases Statement on Foreclosure Moratorium

Calls for 'Flexibility, Understanding, and Business Continuity'

Close up of a charging electric car. Copy space

Electric Vehicle Charging Stations in Common Interest Communities

Where to Put Them - and Who Pays?

The concept of carbon neutral and net zero. natural environment A climate-neutral long-term strategy greenhouse gas emissions targets with green net center icon on hand cap and green background

Climate Change vs. Multifamily Systems

Hotter Summers, Wetter Winters Demand Adaptation